| Name | B-T | Seasons (Years) | Career Record | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | W% | Reg Seas | W% | Post | W% | |||
| John Grace | R-R | 1976, 78-80 (4) | 21-41 | .339 | 21-39 | .350 | 0-2 | .000 |
| Ron Matthews | R-R | 1981-83 (3) | 40-15 | .727 | 36-12 | .750 | 4-3 | .571 |
| Tom Perry | R-R | 2008-25 (18) | 203-97 | .677 | 185-81 | .695 | 18-16 | .529 |
| Pat Phillips | R-R | 2001-07 (7) | 45-76 | .372 | 42-69 | .378 | 3-7 | .300 |
| Dave Saddlemire | L-R | 1984-2000 (17) | 115-172 | .401 | 109-163 | .401 | 6-9 | .400 |
| Corky Van Kleeck | R-R | 1977 (1) | 2-12 | .143 | 2-12 | .143 | 0-0 | .--- |
| Name | B-T | Seasons (Years) | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chuck Arel | R-R | 2017-21 (5) | 49-21 |
| Jeff Barton | L-L | 2009-25 (17) | 192-92 |
| Mike Bouffard | L-R | 2000 (1) | 14-6 |
| Nate Brubaker | R-R | 1998 (1) | 8-9 |
| Tom Critchlow Sr. | R-R | 2008, 2016-21 (7) | 74-31 |
| Tim Emery | L-R | 2022-24 (3) | 35-18 |
| Brian Flynn | L-L | 2003, 05-07 (4) | 25-43 |
| Will Goodreau | R-R | 1988-90 (3) | 10-38 |
| Malcolm Huesman | R-R | 2025 (1) | 12-6 |
| Josh Kessler | R-R | 2000-04 (5) | 40-51 |
| Jason Lefebvre | R-R | 2024-25 (2) | 24-12 |
| Jay Leone | R-R | 2002 (1) | 7-10 |
| John Luter | L-R | 2024-25 (2) | 24-12 |
| Whitney Lyman | R-R | 1991-93 (3) | 19-31 |
| Kevin Mitchell | R-R | 2012-13 (2) | 28-10 |
| Pete Monty | R-R | 1984-85 (2) | 15-18 |
| Ryan O'Hara | R-R | 2008-15 (8) | 93-47 |
| Jeff Pecor | R-R | 2025 (1) | 12-6 |
| John Phillips | R-R | 2001 (1) | 9-9 |
| Adam Provost | R-R | 2018-20 (3) | 28-10 |
| Jamie Rozzi | R-R | 2013 (1) | 14-5 |
| Bob Russell | R-R | 2004 (1) | 4-14 |
| TJ Sawyer | R-R | 2011-12 (2) | 29-7 |
| Jeff Tarigo | R-R | 2003 (1) | 6-12 |
| Jim Wood | L-R | 1993-99 (7) | 59-63 |